In the wake of Pope Francis’s death on 21 April 2025, the College of Cardinals will soon file into the Sistine Chapel to elect the 267th successor of Peter. While many Vatican handicappers still tout the familiar Italian favorite, Cardinal Pietro Parolin, a growing bloc of electors created by Francis himself is turning its gaze farther east—toward Filipino prelate Cardinal Luis Antonio “Chito” Tagle. The former archbishop of Manila is hardly a long-shot. Journalists have already christened him the “Asian Francis,” a label that captures both his theological affinity with the late pope and his radiant pastoral style.
Shifting South and East
Francis cracked open the Roman windows to the Global South; Tagle would push them wide. Catholics outside Europe now account for well over two-thirds of the Church’s 1.4 billion faithful, and Asia is its fastest-growing frontier. The Annuarium Statisticum Ecclesiae 2023 registers a 0.6 percent jump in Asian Catholics during the latest reporting year, while the continent’s giant—the Philippines—boasts 93 million believers, fully three-quarters of Southeast Asia’s Catholic population. A conclave that wants a shepherd who personifies that tectonic shift will find Tagle less an exotic experiment than demographic common sense.
Francis in Flip-Flops
Francis personally awarded red hats to 108 of the 135 electors, and they are unlikely to sabotage the synodal reforms they helped launch. Tagle is the obvious continuity candidate. As president of Caritas Internationalis he championed migrants and climate justice; as archbishop he washed the feet of street sweepers and drug addicts; and in Rome he defended Francis’s more welcoming approach toward LGBTQ+ Catholics. Analysts therefore describe him as “Francis in flip-flops,” someone who would deepen—rather than dilute—the pastoral revolution of mercy and compassion.
Seasoned Administrator
Critics sometimes caricature global-South cardinals as charming outsiders, yet Tagle has accumulated real Roman seasoning. Since 2019 he has served as pro-prefect of the Dicastery for Evangelization—essentially the Vatican’s mission command tower created by the reform constitution Praedicate Evangelium—and he sits on the Patrimony of the Holy See and Divine Worship dicasteries. The portfolio is broad enough to prove administrative steel, yet mercifully free of the financial or abuse scandals that have tarnished some better-known curial chiefs.
Wired Polyglot
If Francis was the first pontiff to tweet, Tagle is the first genuine YouTube cardinal. His Lenten reflections regularly draw six-figure views, and his effortless code-switching among his native Tagalog, English, Italian, Spanish, French, and Latin allows him to preach on every continent without an army of translators. In an age when the Church’s credibility crisis demands an evangelizer-in-chief who can speak straight to camera—and to wounded hearts—those multimedia gifts are pure gold. A voting body stocked with bishops under seventy knows that evangelization in 2025 happens as much on smartphones as in churches.
Global South Bloc
Conclave outcomes are decided not only by charisma but by coalitions. Italy still fields the largest national bloc, yet for the first time Europeans now form a minority of electors. Latin America sends 24, Africa 19, and Asia 17. Tagle can plausibly stitch together an alliance of Global South cardinals eager for representation, supplemented by reform-minded Europeans who want the Francis agenda locked in. At 67 his relatively young age makes him vigorous enough to circle the globe yet seasoned enough that only the most reactionary elements fear a quarter-century pontificate.
Western Hurdles
To be sure, Tagle faces headwinds. Some Vatican insiders whisper that his disarming humility masks managerial softness while others fret that a Filipino pope would lack the geopolitical gravitas needed while Europe is at war. Because Tagle’s mother is of Chinese-Filipino descent, a handful of China-hawks worry about optics in the still-tense Vatican–Beijing dialogue. Yet these objections pale beside the persuasive narrative of a pastor-theologian who embodies Catholicism’s dynamism in Asia while keeping Francis’s ministry of mercy front and center in church governance.
Pacific Spring
Twelve years ago I wrote that the first Latin American pontificate heralded Catholicism’s southward leap. Today the electors stand on the brink of a Pacific Spring. If they desire a pope who can speak to the fast-growing flock of Asia, evangelize via social media, and deepen the preferential option for the poor and marginalized, Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle offers the full package. In the stillness of the Sistine Chapel, the affable cardinal from Manila may well find the ballots to trade his barong for the white cassock and with it usher in the first Asian papacy in the Church’s two-millennia history.
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In