They Say the Church Doesn’t Listen to Men

They Say the Church Doesn’t Listen to Men November 16, 2024

a bathroom sign with stick figures representing "men" and "women." There is an arrow pointing toward the "men" side of the sign
image via Pixabay

 

A Catholic gentleman on social media said that our current situation with male voters was because no one was listening to men– that the Catholic Church hasn’t listened to men.

At least, he said words to that effect. I didn’t see the tweet before it was deleted because of the outcry. But I’ve been thinking about the assertion ever since. It makes me sad. In the Year of Our Lord 2024, somebody apparently decided that the problem with everything was that the Catholic Church doesn’t listen to men. We have left men behind. We need to give more sympathy to the plight of poor forgotten men.

It’s not the first time I’ve heard such things, of course. It seems like Catholics are always thinking of how little they think of men.

“We’ve neglected men,” says the church in which no woman is ever allowed any authority whatsoever.
“We need to have more male spaces,” says the 2000-year-old church which recently begrudgingly let women be altar servers and lectors if they must.

“We’ve become too feminine” says the male prelate who wears silk and lace dresses in order to look “traditional.”

“Where is the outreach to MEN?” asks the Church which has one-seventh of the sacraments restricted so that only a man can ever get it, and all the top positions necessarily given to the men who have that sacrament and to nobody else.

“Can’t anyone think of the MEN?” says the theologian, who studies the texts of a 2000-year-old church which did not name a female Doctor of the Church until 1970.

“We are neglecting MEN!” says the Catholic NFP consultant, who demands that women fill out a complex calendar with their basal body temperature and cervical secretions and then palpate her cervix, carefully, so as not to accidentally masturbate, and write that down as well– all so that she can have a little space between pregnancies while avoiding mortal sin.  Her husband’s part of this complicated job is to forego sexual intercourse now and then.

“Why can’t somebody think of the plight of MEN?” says the Catholic OB-gyn who convinces a lady to put off the hysterectomy she desperately needs in case God isn’t done giving her children yet.

“Our society is crumbling because feminists want MEN to be less MASCULINE” says the bishop, who quietly moved the priest who abused an adult woman in the confessional to another church, because it’s easy to write that one off as the woman’s fault and not “real” abuse. If it were an altar boy, that would be different.

“Let’s have a special ministry to our boys, free of female influence, so that they can grow up to be strong MEN,” says the youth minister, who turns a blind eye to the boys who snap girls’ bras and harass them at the Catholic high school.

“If only we would train up our sons to be strong MEN, we could change the whole culture,” says the Catholic homeschooling mother who forces her daughters to wear floor-length denim dresses with turtlenecks, for fear their knees and collarbones will tempt a man to rape them and it will be all their fault.

“Let’s start a cenacle to pray for the chastity of our MEN, which is so often under attack,” says the faithful wife with ten children, who lies there obediently staring at the ceiling nightly while her husband scratches his itch, because she thinks it’s a mortal sin to tell him she’d rather not.

“I force my boys to go out for football every year so they’ll be masculine instead of giving in to our culture which has forgotten real MEN,” says the good Catholic mom, whose sons keep getting worse and worse concussions at football practice.
“We have to stop giving in to touchy feely effeminate culture and expect our sons to be MEN,” says the stern Catholic father, who doesn’t know his son has severe depression and has been considering suicide, because the son doesn’t think he can talk about his feelings.
Well, when I put it that way, I guess it’s true the Church isn’t listening to men very much. The Church isn’t listening at all, to anyone, and it’s hurting everyone including men.
But it’s not because the Church has failed to consider men.
And now I’m sadder than ever.

Mary Pezzulo is the author of Meditations on the Way of the Cross, The Sorrows and Joys of Mary, and Stumbling into Grace: How We Meet God in Tiny Works of Mercy.

Steel Magnificat operates almost entirely on tips. To tip the author, donate to “The Little Portion” on paypal or Mary Pezzulo on venmo

"Medicare for All, by legislation"

Thoughts On the Killing of Brian ..."
"The buck has to stop with someone in a company like that. Who do you ..."

Thoughts On the Killing of Brian ..."
"I wasn't really speculating about this specific death, but about the way other ultra rich ..."

Thoughts On the Killing of Brian ..."
"I certainly wouldn't put it beyond their scope morally. The picture is less clear on ..."

Thoughts On the Killing of Brian ..."

Browse Our Archives